From:  Functional lignin hydrogels for biosensors and biomedical therapy

 A comparative table for the preparation methods of lignin-based hydrogels.

MethodPrinciple/MechanismAdvantagesLimitationsScalabilityApplicationsReferences
Interpenetrating Polymer Network (IPN/ semi-IPN)Formation of two independent networks; lignin incorporated via physical interpenetrating or semi-IPN; free radical polymerizationImproves mechanical strength, toughness, and stability; multifunctional properties’ enhanced swelling behaviourMulti-step synthesis; may require organic solventsModerateDrug delivery, biomedical hydrogels, responsive materials[26, 50]
Crosslinking copolymerizationSimultaneous polymerization of monomers with lignin acting as crosslinkerSimple method; cost-effective; high swelling and water retention; biodegradable material possibleUse of chemical crosslinkers and initiators may cause toxicity; less precise structureHigh (industrial friendly)Superabsorbent hydrogels, agriculture, wastewater treatment[52, 54]
Crosslinking grafted lignin and monomersGrafting functional monomers onto lignin backbone followed by crosslinkingEnhanced reactivity; stronger and more stable network; tunable properties; mild reaction conditionsDifficult to control grafting density; heterogeneity; reproducibility issuesModerateBiomedical materials, coatings, controlled drug release[50, 55]
ATRP/RAFT (controlled radical polymerization)Controlled/living radical polymerization using “graft-from” or “graft-onto” strategies for precise architectureExcellent control over molecular weight, structure, and functionality; advanced material designATRP: requires metal catalysts (toxicity, purification); RAFT: requires special agents, longer time, higher costLow to moderateAdvanced drug delivery systems, smart hydrogels, sensors[5759]