From:  Biliary tract cancers: advances in diagnostic and management

 Selected trials evaluating liquid biopsy in bile in BTCs

Bile cfDNA
YearAuthorsTrial typePopulationAssayConcordance rate bile/tissueNotable results
2019Shen et al. [78]Retrospective, single-center observational study
  • 10 patients

  • AJCC stage II-IV BTCs patients (4 gallbladder carcinomas and 6 with CCA)

Customized panel of 150 tumor-related genes

Overall mutation concordance:

  • 90% (9/10) concordant mutations between bile cfDNA and tumor tissue DNA

High mutational concordance:

  • 70% (7/10) patients exhibited > 50% mutational concordance between bile cfDNA and tumor tissue DNA

Bile-based liquid biopsy features high concordance with blood samples and tumor tissue:

  • SNV/indel detection:

    • 18 out of 19 tumor variants were detected in bile cfDNA, achieving a sensitivity of 94.7% and specificity of 99.9%

  • CNV detection:

    • 15 out of 20 tumor CNVs were identified in bile cfDNA, with a sensitivity of 75.0% and specificity of 98.9%

  • Therapeutic target CNVs identified in bile cfDNA:

    • ERBB2, CDK6, MET, PIK3CA, ROS1, CCNE1, and FLT1

2022Li et al. [79]Retrospective single-center study
  • 13 patients

  • AJCC stage I-IV BTCs (7 gallbladder 3 other)

Customized xGen lockdown probe panel with 425 predefined cancer-related genes

Bile vs. plasma vs. tissue:

  • cfDNA yield (n = 11): median 1,918 (bile) vs. 63.1 ng/mL (plasma) (P = 0.0017)

  • Detection rate: 84.6% vs. 53.8% vs. 100%

  • Median MAF: 1.51–2.68% vs. 1.20% vs. 16.32%

  • Top-10 gene concordance: 90% vs. 85% vs. 35%

Genomic profiling of bile (supernatant/pellet) showed significantly higher concordance with tumor tissue alterations than plasma
2022Arechederra et al. [81]Prospective cohort
  • 68 patients

  • Suspicious biliary strictures

Bilemut NGS assay
  • KRAS: 18 mutations were detected in tissue samples, with 5 additional mutations identified exclusively in bile

  • TP53: 13 mutations were detected in tissue samples; 4 additional mutations were found only in bile, while 1 mutation present in tissue was not detected in bile

Superior performance demonstrated in 30 paired bile and tissue samples:

  • Sensitivity: 96.4%

  • Specificity: 69.2%

AJCC: American Joint Committee on Cancer; BTCs: biliary tract cancers; CCA: cholangiocarcinoma; cfDNA: cell-free DNA; CNV: copy number variation; MAF: mutant allele frequency; NGS: next-generation sequencing; SNV: single nucleotide variation