From:  Biliary tract cancers: advances in diagnostic and management

 Selected trials evaluating liquid biopsy in blood in BTCs

YearAuthorsTrial typePopulationAssayConcordance rate liquid/tissueNotable results
Localized BTCs
2023Yoo et al. [58]Randomized phase II
  • 101 patients

  • R0/R1 resected eCCA and regional lymph-node metastases, randomized to gemcitabine-cisplatin versus capecitabine

Signatera, tumor-informed assayNo comparison to tissuePatients with positive ctDNA before adjuvant chemotherapy had shorter RFS than those with negative ctDNA
Metastatic BTCs
2019Mody et al. [61]Retrospective study
  • 124 patients

  • Locally advanced or metastatic BTC (≈ 70% intrahepatic; early-onset < 50 vs. ≥ 50 years)

Guardant®No comparison to tissueBlood-based liquid biopsy can be used for molecular characterization and can identify clinically relevant alterations including 5% IDH1 and 7% FGFR2 mutations
2019Ettrich et al. [62]Retrospective study
  • 32 patients

  • Unresectable locally advanced or metastatic cholangiocarcinoma (UICC stage III/IV; gallbladder cancer excluded), all indicated for palliative chemotherapy

QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit for ctDNA extraction NGS of 15 gene panel, selected frequently mutated genesNo comparison to tissue
  • Variant allele frequency correlates with tumor load and PFS

  • 63% of therapy-naive patients experienced changes in their mutational profiles during chemotherapy

  • Patients with mutations via blood-based liquid biopsy in BAP1, PBRM1, KRAS, or TP53 show a trend toward shorter PFS

2020Lamarca et al. [63]Post hoc analysis of patient data collected as part of the prospective ABC-01, -02, and -03
  • 534 patients

  • From the ABC-01/-02/-trial

  • 109 (20.4%) had iCCA; 86 (78.9%) primarily metastatic; 52 (47.7%) with liver-only disease; 66 (60.6%) of these iCCA patients were treated with cisplatin plus gemcitabine

FoundationOne Liquid® Oncomine
  • IDH1 mutation: 100%

  • FGFR2 fusion: 100%

  • FGFR2 mutation: 100%

  • High concordance with tissue analysis

  • 40% targetable alterations detected:

    • IDH1 mutations: 19%

    • FGFR2 alterations: 10% (5% fusions, 5% mutations)

    • ctDNA before palliative treatment not linked to PFS or OS

2020Aguado et al. [64]ctDNA analysis of the randomized phase III trial ClarIDHy
  • 186 patients

  • Previously treated, advanced iCCA

ctDNA/digital PCRIDH1: 92% concordance between plasma ctDNA and tissue samples
  • mIDH1 detection in plasma ctDNA and tumor tissue was concordant in 92% of samples (193/210)

  • Among ivosidenib-treated patients, IDH1 mutation clearance occurred in 10/36 (28%) with PFS ≥ 2.7 months versus 0/40 with PFS < 2.7 months

  • No IDH1 mutation clearance was observed in any placebo-treated patients (n = 49), regardless of outcome

2021Chen et al. [65]Retrospective study
  • 150 patients

  • Metastatic BTCs

QIAamp Circulating Nucleic Acid Kit for cfDNA extraction
  • TP53: 35.1% in ctDNA vs. 40.4% in tissue samples

  • KRAS: 20.1% in ctDNA vs. 22.6% in tissue samples

  • 94.8% of patients showed at least one change detected in their ctDNA

  • Median maximum somatic allele frequency was 6.47% (0.1–34.8%)

  • Higher tumor mutation burden: patients with mutations in LRP1B, TP53, or ERBB family genes had significantly higher tumor mutation burden

2021Okamura et al. [72]Observational genomic profiling study conducted under the UCSD-PREDICT prospective protocol (NCT02478931)
  • 121 patients

  • Pathologically confirmed BTCs

Guardant®
  • Overall population:

    • TP53: 68%

    • KRAS: 80%

    • PIK3CA: 90%

  • Metastatic site vs. Primary tumor:

    • TP53: 78% vs. 65%

    • KRAS: 100% vs. 74%

    • PIK3CA: 100% vs. 87%

  • Common genetic alterations:

    • ctDNA: TP53 (38%), KRAS (28%), PIK3CA (14%)

    • Tissue-DNA: TP53 (44%), CDKN2A/B (33%), KRAS (29%)

  • Clinical outcomes:

    • Matched therapy: longer PFS (HR 0.60, P = 0.047) and higher disease control (61% vs. 35%, P = 0.04)

    • Unmatched therapy: shorter PFS and lower disease control

2021Yang et al. [73]Multicohort observational analysis
  • 187 patients

  • ICI cohort 1 (n = 43): PD-1 inhibitor + lenvatinib

  • ICI cohort 2 (n = 108): other ICI-based regimens

  • Non-ICI cohort (n = 36): non-ICI therapies

MagMAX cfDNA isolation Kit; TIANamp genomic DNA KitNo comparison to tissue

CNV detection by liquid biopsy can predict response to immunotherapy

  • Lower CNV risk scores were associated with higher clinical benefit rates in both ICI cohorts

  • Patients with low CNV risk scores exhibited lower rates of PD and higher rates of SD and PR

  • Higher disease control rate was observed in low CNV risk groups compared to high-risk groups

  • Elevated CNV risk scores were linked to increased PD rates in both ICI cohorts

2022Berchuck et al. [68]Retrospective, multi-institutional study
  • 1,671 patients

  • Advanced BTCs

Guardant®
  • IDH1: 87% concordance between cfDNA and tissue samples

  • BRAF V600E: 100% concordance

  • FGFR2 fusions: 18% concordance

Targetable alterations detected in 44% of patients
2025Hwang et al. [67]Retrospective single-center study
  • 102 patients

  • Systemic treatment-naive advanced BTCs (49% iCCA, 26.5% eCCA, 24.5% gallbladder cancer)

Oncomine Comprehensive Assay and AlphaLiquid®100 panels
  • IDH1 mutations: sensitivity: 100%; PPV: 71.4%

  • PIK3CA mutations: sensitivity: 100%; PPV: 83.3%

  • BRCA1/2 mutations: sensitivity: 100%; PPV: 77.8%

  • MET amplifications: sensitivity: 100%; PPV: 100%

  • MSI-high: sensitivity: 100%; PPV: 100%

  • ERBB2 amplifications: sensitivity: 40.0%; PPV: 100%

  • ctDNA identified targetable alterations in 34.3% of patients, including FGFR2 fusions, IDH1 mutations, MSI, ERBB2 amplifications, PIK3CA mutations, BRCA1/2 mutations, and MET amplification

  • A novel FGFR2-TNS1 fusion was detected via ctDNA analysis

  • The highest ctDNA variant allele frequency is associated with chemotherapy outcome

Evaluation of resistance mechanisms during treatment
2017Goyal et al. [74]Prospective translational analysis within the context of the BGJ398 phase II trial
  • 9 patients, 4 of them included in the BGJ398 trial

  • FGFR2 fusion-positive iCCA

Guardant®No comparison to tissue
  • All 3 FGFR2 fusion-positive iCCA patients developed secondary FGFR2 kinase-domain mutations upon progression

  • 2 patients exhibited multiple distinct FGFR2 mutations, indicating polyclonal resistance

BRAF: v-Raf murine sarcoma viral oncogene homolog B; BRCA1/2: breast cancer 1/2; BTCs: biliary tract cancers; cfDNA: cell-free DNA; CNV: copy number variation; ctDNA: circulating tumor DNA; eCCA: extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma; FGFR2: fibroblast growth factor receptor 2; HR: hazard ratio; iCCA: intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; IDH1: isocitrate dehydrogenase 1; MSI: microsatellite instability; NGS: next-generation sequencing; OS: overall survival; PCR: polymerase chain reaction; PD: progressive disease; PD-1: programmed cell death 1; PFS: progression-free survival; PPV: positive predictive value; PR: partial response; RFS: recurrence-free survival; SD: stable disease