PD-L1 expression on TETs
Reference | TM | TC | Antibody of PD-L1 | IHC staining criteria of positivity | TM positivity rate | TC positivity rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Weissferdt et al. [47] | 74/100 (74.00%) | 26/100 (26.00%) | Clone EPR4877 | MS > 5% | 64.00% | 54.00% |
Arbour et al. [48] | 12/23 (52.17%) | 11/23 (47.83%) | Clone E1L3N | MS > 25% | 92.00% | 36.00% |
Suster et al. [49] | - | 21 | Clone SP142 | MS > 50% | NA | 71.40% |
Higuchi et al. [50] | 31/39 (79.50%) | 8/39 (20.50%) | Clone 28-8 | MS ≥ 1% | 51.60% | 62.50% |
Wei et al. [51] | 100/169 (59.20%) | 69/169 (40.80%) | Clone E1L3N | MS > 50% | 36.00% | 37.00% |
Duan et al. [52] | 20/33 (60.60%) | 13/33 (39.40%) | Clone Ab58810 | Intensity of staining score (1–3); median value of all scores as the cut-off value | 65.00% | 46.20% |
Funaki et al. [53] | - | 43 | Clone SP142 | MS > 50% | NA | 60.50% |
Katsuya et al. [54] | 101/139 (72.60%) | 38/139 (27.40%) | Clone E1L3N | H-score: score 3 [staining intensity (0–3) × % of positive cells (0–100%)] | 23.00% | 70.00% |
Padda et al. [55] | 65/69 (94.20%) | 4/69 (5.80%) | Clone 15 | Score 3 (intensity of MS 0–3) | 68.00% | 75.00% |
Marchevsky et al. [56] | 38/46 (82.60%) | 8/46 (17.40%) | Clone SP142 | MS ≥ 6% | 92.00% | 50.00% |
Enkner et al. [8] | 37/72 (51.30%) | 35/72 (48.70%) | Clone E1L3N | H-score (cut-off value NA) | 89.00% | 53.00% |
Katsuya et al. [57] | 12/30 (40.00%) | 18/30 (60.00%) | Clone E1L3N | Score ≥ 1 (intensity of MS 0–3) | 67.00% | 41.00% |
Yokoyama et al. [58] | 82 | - | Clone EPR1161 | Youden’s index > 38% | 53.70% | NA |
Tiseo et al. [59] | 87/107 (81.30%) | 20/107 (18.70%) | Clone E1L3N | H-score: score 3 (intensity of MS 0–3) | 18.00% | 65.00% |
Owen et al. [60] | 32/35 (91.40%) | 3/35 (8.60%) | Clone 22C3 | Score 1 (intensity of MS 0–5) | 81.00% | 100.00% |
Hakiri et al. [61] | 81 | - | Clone SP142 | MS ≥ 1% | 27.00% | NA |
Guleria et al. [62] | 84 | - | Clone SP263 | MS > 25% | 82.00% | NA |
Chen et al. [63] | 40/70 (57.00%) | 30/70 (43.00%) | Clone SP142 | MS ≥ 5% | 37.50% | 76.70% |
Bagir et al. [64] | 38/44 (86.30%) | 6/44 (13.70%) | Clone AM26531AF-N | MS > 5% | 81.60% | 83.30% |
Ishihara et al. [65] | 55/66 (83.30%) | 11/66 (16.70%) | Clone SP263 | MS > 25% | 92.70% | 72.70% |
Berardi et al. [66] | 63/68 (92.60%) | 5/68 (7.40%) | Clone 28-8 | MS > 1% | Overall: 25.00% |
NA: not available; -: blank cells
SL: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigations, Writing—original draft, Writing—review & editing. MA and SC: Methodology, Investigations. RF: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigations, Writing—original draft, Writing—review & editing, Supervision.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
According to Italian law, the content of this article does not require ethical approval.
According to Italian law, the content of this article does not require consent to participate. The images could be used for diulgative purpose for the italian law, since they are totally anonymized.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
© The Author(s) 2024.