Main glycosylation changes found in PSA from cancer origin and the advantages of the corresponding detection assays over the conventional PSA tests (representative examples published since 2007)

Alteration in glycosylation (versus normal PSA)AssayReported main advantages over PSA conventional detectionLimitationsReference
Increased total fucosylationSolid-phase permethylation and MALDI-MSPre-screening method to aid early PC detection-[170]

Higher content of α2,3-linked sialic acid

Lower content of α2,6-linked sialic acid

Lectin immunosorbent assay, using SNA, MAA-I, and MAA-II

Low limits of detection (0.04–1.35 ng/mL) and good reproducibility (%CVs < 10%)

Total SNA assay (AUC = 0.71) performed better than %fPSA (AUC = 0.54) in its diagnostic grey zone between 10% and 20%

Direct analysis of PSA glycosylation in sera

High-throughput assay

Sufficient limit of detection to analyze PSA sialylation in non-cancer sera with < 10 ng/mL of PSA

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings

The assay should be completed with the inclusion of immunosorbent assays using lectins that recognize other carbohydrate moieties (e.g., fucose)

[171]
Increased expression of α1,2-linked fucose and β-GalNAc residuesLectin-affinity chromatography and ELISA, using TJA-IITJA-II-bound PSA content and TJA-II binding ratios (%) could be used to discriminate between PC and BPH with more than a 95% probability-[61]
Increased fucosylation of fPSAEnzyme-linked immunosorbent lectin assay, using UEA-I

92% Specific and 69% sensitive for PC over BPH; in comparison, fPSA measurement was 70% specific and 56% sensitive (threshold set to 25% tPSA) for PC over BPH (PSA in the range of 4–10 ng/mL)

Methodology compatible with equipment available in the majority of biomedical laboratories

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[172]

Increased levels of core-fucosylated bi-antennary glycans and α2,3-linked sialic acids

Decreased tri-antennary tri-galactosylated glycans and tetra-antennary tetra-sialylated glycans with outer arm fucose

Serum N-glycome release followed by NP- and ccc with fluorescence detection

All chromatographic peaks significantly differentiated PC patients from BPH patients, with improved AUC values over PSA itself

The glycan level may work in a more general patient population than the free/total PSA ratio

Decreases in tri-antennary tri-galactosylated glycans and/or bisected core fucosylated biantennary monosialylated glycans and increases in tetra-antennary tetra-sialylated glycans correlated with tumour spread and patients’ survival

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[173]
GalNAcβ1−4GlcNAc-linked PSA (LacdiNAc-PSA)Immunoassay system with SPFS, using anti-PSA IgG antibody to capture PSA and WFA for the detection of LacdiNAc

Limit of quantification of 0.256 pg/mL tPSA, with a dynamic range of at least five digits and limit of detection of LacdiNAc-PSA of 20.0 pg/mL

AUC for LacdiNAc-PSA (0.851) was significantly greater than that for tPSA (0.559), and the optimum cut-off gave low false positivity (40.7%) and high sensitivity (88.4%), with specific distinction between PC and BPH within the PSA grey zone (4.0–20.0 ng/mL PSA)

Comparing with recently reported PSA assays, LacdiNAc-PSA was significantly better than pro-PSA and fPSA

Reduced assay time and minimum consumption of reagents

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings

The detection could be further improved by reducing the influence of nonspecific reactions between fluorescently labelled WFA and serum proteins

[174]
α2,3-Linked sialylation as an additional terminal N-glycan on fPSA (S2,3PSA)Magnetic microbead-based immunoassay, using anti-human fPSA monoclonal antibody (8A6) for capture and anti-α2,3-linked sialic acid monoclonal antibody (HYB4) for detectionAUC of 0.84, a sensitivity of 90.6%, and specificity of 64.2% for the diagnosis of PC with S2,3PSA (higher than those with PSA or %fPSA)A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[175]
Increased fucosylation of PSALectin-affinity capturing of fucosylated glycoprotein (using AAL) and protein-antibody immunoreactivity

The fucosylated PSA achieved a better predictive power (AUC = 0.7056) when compared with tPSA (AUC = 0.6558)

Using the ratio of fucosylated PSA as a predictive marker, it achieved even better performance when compared with the total serum PSA, in discriminating aggressive from non-aggressive tumours

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[176]

Decrease in core fucose

Increase in α2,3-sialic acid percentage of PSA

Free PSA immunopurification followed by enzyme-linked lectin assay with PhoSL (detection of core fucosylation) and SNA lectin-affinity chromatography (detection of PSA α2,3-linked sialic acid level)

A cut-off value of 0.86 of the PSA core fucose ratio could distinguish high-risk PC patients from BPH with 90% sensitivity and 95% specificity, with an AUC of 0.94

A cut-off value of 30% of the α2,3-sialic acid percentage of PSA discriminated between high-risk PC and the groups of BPH, low-, and intermediate-risk PC, with a sensitivity of 85.7% and specificity of 95.5%, and an AUC of 0.97 (better than using tPSA or %fPSA in the diagnostic grey zone)

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[177]
Increased α2,3-linked sialyl N-glycan-carrying PSA ratio (%S2,3PSA)Automated micro-total immunoassay system (μTAS system) using MAA

The limit of detection of S2,3PSA was 0.05 ng/mL with a %CV < 3.1%

The AUC for the detection of PC for the S2,3PSA ratio (%S2,3PSA) with a cut-off value of 43.85% (0.8340) was much superior than the total PSA (AUC = 0.5062)

The optimum cut-off point giving high specificity (72.0%) at 80% sensitivity was determined to be 42.20% of %S2,3PSA (significantly higher than that for conventional PSA testing)

Assay time < 10 min

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[178]
Increased fucosylation of PSALectin immunoassays using LCA and AAL followed by clinical PSA immunoassay

Fucosylated PSA-AAL had the best performance (AUC = 0.909), followed by total PSA (AUC = 0.881), fucosylated PSA-LCA (AUC = 0.839), %fucosylated PSA-AAL (AUC = 0.822), and %fucosylated PSA-LCA (AUC = 0.594)

Fucosylated PSA-AAL, %fucosylated PSA-AAL, and fucosylated PSA-LCA levels could be effective biomarkers to differentiate aggressive PC from non-aggressive disease

The combined use of fucosylated PSA and %fucosylated PSA could be used in place of tPSA with potentially improved performance in identifying aggressive disease

A larger sample size would be needed to validate the reported findings[179]

AUC: area under the curve; CV: coefficient of variation; %fPSA: percentage of free PSA; MALDI-MS: matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization MS; NP: normal phase; PC: prostate cancer; SPFS: surface plasmon field-enhanced fluorescence spectrometry; tPSA: total PSA; WAX: weak anion exchange; IgG: immunoglobulin G; HPLC: high-performance liquid chromatography