In Japan, about 2,200 people are newly diagnosed with bladder cancer each year, and about 9,000 people die. The number of new cases of bladder cancer is increasing every year [1]. More than 50% of non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) patients experience recurrence within one to two years after transurethral resection of bladder tumor (TURBT) surgery, and NMIBC is characterized by a very high postoperative recurrence rate [2]. Furthermore, TURBT is an invasive surgical procedure with many intra- and postoperative complications such as bleeding, bladder perforation, and obturator nerve reflex. The risk of recurrence of bladder cancer will increase with the elderly population due to the increase in life expectancy. Therefore, especially in elderly and frail patients with NMIBC, repeated recurrences may require multiple hospitalizations for TURBT. This leads to a huge emotional and financial stress for the patient. If bladder cancer recurs frequently, the patient is at risk of developing muscle invasive bladder cancer and will require radical cystectomy. Therefore, it is desirable to create a new treatment method that is less burdenful to patients and reduces the risk of postoperative recurrence of NMIBC or progression to muscle invasive cancer compared to conventional TURBT in bladder cancer treatment.

Treatment of large or multiple bladder tumors with TURBT under anesthesia has advantages in terms of cancer control with complete resection. However, if the recurrent tumor is a small low-risk bladder tumor, TURBT under anesthesia may result in a shorter operative time and a higher risk of anesthesia and complications. Therefore, TURBT without spinal or general anesthesia is not feasible due to its painful and invasive procedure for patients.

Treatment with 980-nm wavelength diode lasers has been applied to evaporation techniques due to the property that its energy is absorbed by both water molecules and oxidized hemoglobin. Diode lasers at 980 nm have been reported to provide excellent hemostasis and evaporation in contact laser vaporization of the prostate (CVP) surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) in the urological field [3–5]. This also allows CVP surgery to have a high hemostatic performance and the advantage of being performed without discontinuing anticoagulant medications. Naturally, the 980 nm diode laser evaporation technique can be applied to NMIBC. Hermann et al. [6, 7] reported that transurethral laser ablation (TULA) for NMIBC is superior to conventional TURBT in terms of lower complication rates and recurrence rates at 12 months after surgery. TULA using a combination of a laser fiber with a flexible cystoscope can reduce the stress on the urethra and significantly decrease pain. This point leads to the practice of treatment under local anesthesia without the need for spinal or general anesthesia.

There are no reports from Japan on the efficacy and safety of TULA for NMIBC. Therefore, this study reports initial experience of treatment efficacy regarding intraoperative and postoperative outcomes of TULA for recurrent NMIBC in Japan.

TURBT is the standard and essential surgical technique for NMIBC. The skill of the surgeon has a significant impact on outcomes and complication rates in TURBT. Intraoperative complications of TURBT include rebleeding, bladder perforation, obturator nerve reflex, and urinary tract infection. To reduce the incidence of such complications by TURBT, Li et al. [8] were the first to investigate evaporation using several laser generators for NMIBC. They reported that ablation with the holmium- yttrium-aluminum-garnet (YAG) laser, 2,000-nm and 1,900-nm thulium-YAG lasers, and potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP) green light laser not only reduced the complication rate but also decreased the postoperative recurrence rate compared to TURBT [8–13]. Their review revealed that laser ablation for NMIBC may be superior to conventional TURBT.

The 980-nm wavelength diode laser technology is expected to bring many advantages to the surgical treatment of NMIBC. The 980-nm wavelength characteristic allows efficient non-contact hemostasis and high hemostatic performance [14, 15]. First, the 980-nm wavelength diode laser has a large absorption coefficient for oxidizing hemoglobin to heat and reliably coagulate the blood vessels of the tumor and interrupt blood flow. Secondly, the low absorption coefficient of water molecules allows penetration into deep tissues and ensures that tumor cells at the base of the tumor are also degenerated. This reduces the possibility of residual tumor cells due to incomplete ablation and allows for a highly curative therapeutic effect. Mao et al. [16] reported a study of 980-nm diode laser en-block resection in 40 NMIBC patients. They reported that 980-nm diode laser can deliver a good hemostatic effect on vascular hemorrhage by applying non-contact laser irradiation from the bleeding point to the tissue surface. Laser thermal transfer to the tissue allows precise incisions with minimal bleeding. As a result, the length of bladder irrigation could be markedly shortened, and no posterior hemorrhage was observed.

European Association of Urology (EAU) guidelines recommend the use of diode lasers for the treatment of bladder outlet obstruction (BOO) and BPH. Laser ablation can provide complete control of intraoperative bleeding in patients on anticoagulants or hemorrhagic disease. Furthermore, laser ablation is listed in the office-fulguration section under evidence level 1a as laser photocoagulation for recurrent Ta low-grade NMIBC [17]. It is stated that laser ablation for carefully selected recurrent NMIBC on an outpatient setting offers important economic and institutional organizational savings and reduces the burden and annoyance of hospitalization for patients and their family.

Pedersen et al. [18] reported a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of recurrent low-grade Ta NMIBC (intermediate risk) treated with laser ablation using the 980-nm diode laser in an outpatient clinic under local anesthesia. They compared TURBT under general anesthesia with TULA under local anesthesia for RFS at 4 months postoperatively. The 4-month postoperative RFS rate was 8% higher for TULA, postoperative quality of life was better with TULA, and minor complications were less frequent with TULA. Thus, TULA is a less invasive procedure with the same oncological outcome and improved postoperative quality of life compared to TURBT. Furthermore, repeated TURBT under general anesthesia has been reported to increase non-cancer specific mortality in low-risk Ta NMIBC patients. There is potential for a lower perioperative complication rate and lower non-cancer specific mortality by replacing TURBT with TULA.

This study showed TULA using a 980-nm diode laser was significantly shorter than TURBT in terms of perioperative results: operative time, hospital stay, catheterization, bladder irrigation, and postoperative hospital stay. Regarding the occurrence of complications, TULA was observed to be less prevalent than TURBT in all cases. The findings suggest that TULA may constitute a less invasive treatment compared with TURBT in NMIBC. Furthermore, postoperative RFS was found to be significantly prolonged compared to TURBT. This study demonstrated favorable outcomes with respect to postoperative recurrence in TULA. Elderly patients with NMIBC with multiple diseases require gentler treatment than conventional TURBT under general anesthesia. The utilization of the diode laser technique has the potential to facilitate this objective. In addition, this diode laser technique has the potential to provide painless treatment for the majority of low-grade urothelial carcinomas using a flexible cystoscope under local anesthesia in an outpatient setting.

From a clinical perspective, it is important to consider some limitations of this study. Firstly, the study is a single-center, preliminary, retrospective study, and the follow-up period is short due to the small number of eligible patients and the low external validity of our results. Furthermore, the results of TULA treated by a single surgeon and the method of enrolling patients may have introduced selection bias and affected the validity of the conclusions. Secondly, there may be potential bias in the patient backgrounds of the TULA and TURBT cohorts. This study was a retrospective observational study. Since treatment selection was left to the discretion of the attending physician, differences in background factors occurred between groups. Furthermore, due to the nature of retrospective studies and constraints related to the number of cases and missing data, it was difficult to perform adequate statistical adjustments using propensity score analysis or multivariate analysis. This study was unable to clearly demonstrate that TULA is superior to TURBT regarding RFS. The RFS results were exploratory and not definitive. Consequently, the necessity for large-scale prospective case studies incorporating multicenter studies and protracted follow-up periods is apparent in order to resolve these limitations in the future.

In this study, the results of using a diode laser at 980-nm wavelength for NMIBC patients proved to be a promising, effective, and safe treatment. These laser techniques have demonstrated excellent hemostatic properties and satisfactory postoperative results. This study provides a basis for further research on the utilization of diode laser in ablation techniques in future studies. Long-term follow-up incorporating prospective RCTs is needed to validate our promising short-term results.